Order by 1am and receive tomorrow 20% off your app order Sign up for email exclusives Earn Cult Status Points
NEW HERE? ENJOY 20% OFF | CODE: CBNEW
TRIED AND TESTED

THE BEST NATURAL MASCARAS (AND WHY BROWN IS BACK)

THE BEST NATURAL MASCARAS (AND WHY BROWN IS BACK)
Updated 16/11/2026

Big, spidery lashes have had their moment. Right now, the mascaras we’re reaching for (and the ones you’re searching for) are the ones that barely look like mascara at all: soft, separated, lifted and, more and more often, brown. Think of it as the lash version of a skin tint.

Below, we break down what actually makes a mascara look natural, why brown mascara is having a moment and the formulas worth a place in your makeup bag, whether your lashes are fair, fine or simply in need of a little definition.

In this article

  • What makes a mascara look natural?
  • Why brown mascara is back
  • The best brown mascaras
  • The best natural-look black mascaras
  • Natural mascara formulas
  • How to get a natural mascara look
  • Natural mascara FAQs

What makes a mascara look natural?

A natural mascara look comes down to three things. First, the formula: lightweight, buildable textures add length and definition without weighing lashes down or sticking them together. Second, the brush: slim, comb-like or flexible wands get right to the root and separate every lash. Third, the shade: soft black, brown-black and brown all define without the hard outline of jet black.

Tubing mascaras deserve a mention too. Rather than painting lashes, they wrap each one in a fine coating for clean, defined length that slides off with warm water. Find out more in our guide to tubing mascara.

Why brown mascara is back

Brown mascara used to be the secret of the very fair-lashed. Now it’s one of the most-searched lash looks around, and it’s easy to see why. Brown adds definition without a harsh edge, so lashes look longer and fuller but still believably yours.

It’s especially flattering on fair, blonde or red lashes, with light brows or alongside a warm, soft makeup palette, where jet black can look a little stark in daylight. Not ready to give up black? Brown-black shades sit neatly in the middle. Find every shade in our brown mascara collection.

The best brown mascaras

From everyday buildable formulas to lifting and lengthening wands, these are the brown mascaras we rate.

  • Saie Mascara 101 in Brown: a buildable, everyday formula that lifts and separates, in a soft brown that suits fair lashes beautifully. New to the brand? Read our guide to Saie.
  • Westman Atelier Eye Want You Mascara in Clean Le Brun: a warm, rich brown with an hourglass-shaped brush that reaches every lash. One coat looks natural; two turns up the drama.
  • Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara in Espresso: deep espresso brown for serious length, with a gently curved wand that catches even the shortest lashes.
  • Armani Vertigo Mascara in Coffee Brown: a looped brush separates as it coats, so you can go from barely there to fully defined in a couple of strokes.
  • MAC MACStack Mascara in Chestnut Brown: made for layering. Stop at one coat for soft definition or keep stacking for volume.
  • Sweed Lash Lift Mascara in Dark Brown: the comb-like wand gets right to the root to lift and separate, which makes it ideal if your lashes tend to point straight ahead.
  • Kosas Soulgazer Lengthening and Lifting Peptide Mascara: a curved brush and weightless texture for wide-awake lashes, in brown as well as black.

Rounding things off, BY TERRY Terrybly Mascara in Moka Brown and Hermès Trait d’Hermès Mascara in Brun Bistre are the luxury picks, while the Sculpted by Aimee Brown MyMascara Mini is made for your handbag. For more shades, see all our brown mascaras.

The best natural-look black mascaras

Not every natural mascara has to be brown. If you prefer the definition of black, look for buildable formulas and separating brushes that give you lashes, not spikes.

Saie Mascara 101 and Westman Atelier Eye Want You both come in black as well as brown, so you can switch shades without switching formulas. Kosas Soulgazer in Hypnotize lifts without stiffness, while Hourglass Unlocked gives tubing-style length in the original black. For something lighter still, VIEVE Modern Mascara and Anastasia Beverly Hills Lash Sculpt both build from subtle to defined. Want more length or volume? Our guide to the best mascaras for every lash goal has you covered, or see all our mascaras.

Natural mascara formulas

For some, natural mascara is less about the finish and more about what goes into the tube. If that’s you, Ere Perez is a good place to start: its Natural Almond Mascara and Avocado Waterproof Mascara are built around the oils in their names and come in black or brown. RMS Beauty, founded by makeup artist Rose-Marie Swift, adds peptides to its Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara, while the 19/99 Beauty Lash Tint Mascara gives a just-tinted look in shades including brown and taupe.

Need something that lasts through a rainy commute? Our pick of the best waterproof mascaras has plenty of options.

How to get a natural mascara look

  1. Curl first. A quick curl opens up your eyes, so you need less product to make an impact.
  2. Start at the root. Wiggle the wand where your lashes meet the lid, then sweep up and out. This puts the colour where lashes are thickest and keeps the tips soft.
  3. Stop at one coat. One well-placed coat is usually all a natural look needs. Want more? Add a second straight away, while the first is still wet.
  4. Comb through. A clean spoolie separates anything that’s stuck together.
  5. Go lighter on lower lashes. Skip them altogether, or try brown on the bottom and black on top for definition that still looks soft.

For more tricks, read our guide to making your eyelashes look longer. Creating a full no-makeup makeup look? Our guide to the best natural makeup has the base, blush and lip to match.

Natural mascara FAQs

Is brown mascara more natural than black?

For most people, yes. Brown is closer to the natural colour of lashes, so it adds definition without a harsh outline. If your lashes are very dark, a brown-black or soft black can look just as natural.

Who should wear brown mascara?

Anyone after a softer look, but it’s especially flattering on fair, blonde or red lashes and with light brows, where black can look heavy. It’s also a lovely choice for daytime and no-makeup makeup looks.

Can you wear brown mascara on dark lashes?

Yes. On dark lashes, brown reads as subtle definition rather than an obvious colour, which is exactly the point. If you’re unsure, try it on your lower lashes first.

Does mascara colour depend on eye colour?

It can. Brown flatters almost every eye colour, while shades like plum or navy can make certain eye colours stand out. Our guide to coloured mascara breaks it down by eye colour.

How do I make my mascara look natural?

Choose a lightweight formula in brown or soft black, curl your lashes first, apply one coat from the root and comb through. Ready to find yours? Start with our top 10 mascaras or see all our mascaras.

Related Posts