Super nice color "Classic brown", The quality is good as well. 

Very scratchy and difficult to apply not at all soft as I had expected. Won’t buy again.

This has a really unique texture - it's powdery so you can build it in the waterline. It takes a few applications to make it stay - I do three coats and it lasts most of the day. It's not so good at staying on top of the eyelid, so I use in combo with a liquid eyeliner. I have blue eyes and rubbish eyelashes and this is my hero - in emergencies (ie. mornings, looking rough) I put the Audrey shade along top and bottom waterline and it makes me look like I have thick eyelashes even without mascara. If you're looking for staying power or drama, this prob isn't for you - but for an everyday product that just makes you look BETTER I can't recommend this enough.

Super nice color "Classic brown", suites perfect to me....really perfect cool brown. The quality is good as well.

You need to reapply every 5 minutes! The colour is nice but there are better, longer lasting pencils out there. This one now lives in my handbag to be used only in an emergency!

I own Sophia and Audrey so far. Have oily/combo skin and always have to use eye primer (for reference). I use these shadow pencils every day and they give a beautiful, natural look. I usually tight-line my upper lashes, enhance the lower lashes, and create a small wing. The liners usually stay on, but by the end of the day the wings tend to disappear which doesn’t bother me a whole lot, I can just reapply them once during the day if I feel like it. Since I’ve purchased these shadow pencils, I stopped using my rock n’ kohl liners which I also love! But the shadow pencils give such soft, beautiful yet defined eyes that they are just perfect for daily use. Definite repurchase!

Love at first sight! It’s so firm and soft at the same time! Maybe not perfect as an eyeliner, but really good to detail an eye on the lash line.

I'm a NC42 - 25 and I've been on the look for a nice, subtle dark brown eyeliner basically since I started wearing eyeliner. Amazing in my waterline and lower lash line. It's not obvious when I have it on my eyelids but it gives that "full effect" for my eyelashes. Key here is that this is for a subtle and soft look that's still defined. It's not for exaggeration or drama like a black eyeliner. Glides on like a dream and does a fantastic job for the price.

This eyeliner is not cheap but it is impossible to use. Drags across the eyelid, leaves no colour, end up using my cheapo this was meant to replace! Don’t be fooled by the good marketing, I was!

It’s a beautiful colour and it would be nice to use... but it’s impossible to sharpen! And in the photos it looks a bit greyish and I would love that, but in real life it seems warmer to me...