Got this in my advent calendar. Absolutely horrible, the brush is okay, but as soon as mascara dries it begins to crumble and leave black flakes under the eyes.

Nice packaging. I've struggled a bit with the shape of the brush, but that is probably down to my lack of expertise with this style and I'm hoping this will improve with practice! The texture is quite nice, feels drier compared to other mascaras and no clumping. I did not experience flaking or smudging. 

Ok the packaging is lovely, the brush is really nice - curved and soft silicone type material. The mascara goes on really nicely and quite a subtle amount of length…but it’s not at all buildable, it clumps and then it dries out and leaves you with black confetti under the eyes all day and my lashes feel crispy. Not going to finish the tube and won’t repurchase 

I really like this mascara. I have very short lashes so the build up mascaras end up caking and clumping as they are too thick. This mascara is quite a dry texture but doesn't clump when applying it. It provides a thin layer and I usually use two layers. I find it gives my lashes definition without looking overdone so is good for daily use.  I like the shaped wand as I don't end up poking myself in the eye with it as it is quite slim. recommend this mascara if you want natural looking lashes.

Had a mini of this from the advent calander. The mascara is very dry, does not give a good lash effect and flakes under the eyes. 

So glad I got this in my advent calendar.  It’s a very nice light mascara if you want a natural or an every day look. The  brush is a great shape and can get the very small lashes on each sides. 

I got this in the advent calendar. For me this mascara is perfect as I find the brush the perfect shape and it even gets those annoying tiny eyelashes at the side. I prefer a mascara which is more about highlighting your natural lashes instead of making them thicker which this is brilliant at. So if you are looking for something with a natural look I’d go for this. Very pleased it appeared in the calendar 😊

Very dry formula. First use I was impressed with volume but after several disappointment. In windy weather when eyes are irritated it was stinging my eyes

I don't get the bag reviews. I got in the advent calendar and I am very happy with it. It doesn't clump and is not hard to remove. It's not very dramatic, more of a natural look

I love this formula it’s quite waxy which helps to build length and volume just wish it came in brown