15% off your first order over £25. Code: FIRST15. T&Cs apply.

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara Mini - Supercharged Black 4.5g

Customer Reviews

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara Mini - Supercharged Black 4.5g Customer Reviews

GBP 13.0

£13.00

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara Mini - Supercharged Black 4.5g
Overall Rating : 3.31 / 5 (16 Reviews)
  • 3 5 star reviews
  • 4 4 star reviews
  • 4 3 star reviews
  • 5 2 star reviews
  • 0 1 star reviews
3.31 / 5 (16 Reviews)
  • 3 5 star reviews
  • 4 4 star reviews
  • 4 3 star reviews
  • 5 2 star reviews
  • 0 1 star reviews

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Please remember that results will vary from person to person. We're proud to say that all customer reviews are independent, authentic and do not represent the views of Cult Beauty or The Hut Group.

Disappointed

2

I’m glad I got this in mini version because I don’t like it and won’t be repurchasing. It doesn’t give much length or volume, it smudges more than a ‘normal’ mascara and the vand stabs my eye. Don’t waste your money.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Not smudgeproof

3

This is glorious mascara...to apply! The brush grips every lash keeps them separate coats them well. It's buildable too. However, it smudges for sure, top and bottom across brows and under eyes/ on cheeks. It dries down pretty rapid too so the lengthening effect doesn't last. I want to love it, I really do. But overall I'm disappointed and won't purchase again.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Disappointed

2

Mascara makes my lashes bigger and longer, but after an hour all-black ink is under my lower eyelid and I look like a panda. There are better mascaras for a lower price. Good that I bought a smaller version. Not recommended!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Very disappointed

3

I love the original mascara so I went for this one hoping it will be improved somehow.. I like the brush, the mascara is nice and the lashes look good when applied in two coats. For about an hour, then it gets smudged, flakes all over the face, transferred above the eyes.. Such a disappointment for me. Will definitely not buy again.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

A star short of brilliant

4

Looks good, but smudges easily. I was expecting great things, and was a bit disappointed

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Impressive but only for a bit

3

As a self proclaimed mascara junkie, the lashes are okay but after wearing it three times, I’ve thrown it in the bin because the transfer under my eyes was ridiculous, even using a setting powder on my concealer. Won’t buy again.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Amazing length and lift

5

I have found this mascara amazing. I was quite sceptical of the magnetic formula and I am also not a huge fan of benefit mascara... So was not expecting much, BUT this one is amazing. The brush separates lashes really well and the formula/brush gives a really nice lift which lengthens the lashes without having to curl them first. I found the formula to be a nice consistency which covers the lashes well - would absolutely recommend it if you go for length over volume. I will be buying this again!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Disappointed

2

I thought this mascara would be better than the original but stick to the original! The brush is good however the mascara itself ended up smudged under my eyes by lunchtime. I have persevered however the same thing happens every time I wear it. Can't recommend, although the original is fantastic!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Best I have tried!

5

I have loved Bad Gal Bang since the launch so wasn't expecting to love this more- but honestly the best mascara I have tried. Super thickening & lengthening you get a decent amount of playtime so can really build up if you wish. I would say you need a good remover but who cares... it stays on all day and looks so much better than my other recent mascara purchases. A BIG difference.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Disappointed

3

As someone that normally loves Benefit mascaras, I was super excited for the opportunity to try this but, I have to say I was quite disappointed. It did give me some length but the mascara feels quite dry when applying and didn't give me any additional volume. I normally like volume over length so maybe this one just isn't for me. But what made it really disappointing was that it gave me the dreaded 'panda eyes' at the end of the day. This is an absolute deal-breaker for me and I have to say I won't be reusing this mascara sadly. I'll stick with 'They're Real' next time.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara Mini - Supercharged Black 4.5g Customer Reviews

GBP 13.0

£13.00

benefit They’re Real Magnet Extreme Lengthening and Powerful Lifting Mascara Mini - Supercharged Black 4.5g

Quantity

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )

Other customers bought: