Don’t use this on top of makeup, because it won’t work properly. I do eye make up first, and then I’m just careful with the product I use around this. Lightly pat a bit of setting powder on top of this once it’s dry and this will stay sharp and strong for 24 hours, easily. 

Great liner, does the job, very precise and pigmented. Lasts all day. 

I bought this because I have the black version of this eyeliner, and I thought it would be less harsh against my pale skin. It looks absolutely amazing, really compliments and brings out my blue eyes, but also isn’t noticeably brown per say, just much less goth like than jet black looks on me. As with the black, it’s waterproof, lasts all day and is easy to apply with the foam pen tip. 

Great eye liner! The felt tip makes it easy to create thin lines, great to use as eye liner and graphic liner. I put this on in the morning and it stays smudge free until evening. Also, the actual liner lasts me a long time and doesn’t dry out! 

This is a great eyeliner. Easy to use and glides on the eyelid smoothly without any pulling or tugging. very pigmented so gives a strong beautiful defined look. stays put all day and doesn`t smudge or wear off. This is my 3rd one so far.

I am surprised by good reviews especially about it being waterproof. This is the worst eyeliner I have ever bought. One star for it being easy to use but it is smudging terribly (not talking only about hot days), not lasting at all I used it twice and binned it - not recommended at all

I keep trying other liquid liners, but I come back to this time after time.  It glides on smoothly, lasts all day and is smudge free. The pointed tip helps for doing flicks/wings, which I am not very good at but this eyeliner hides my mistakes well!  The lid also goes on really securely which means you can throw it in your make up bag and not worry about it popping off and the product drying out. 

Easy to use and holds properly all day..haven’t tried it during summer yet but very happy so far

Stays on for a long time, dark black, and easy to use. I repurchase this eyeliner often.

I love the way this feels, and it does make my skin look/feel more glowy and hydrated. However, it also amplifies some redness on my skin.