I love this mascara, it makes my eye lashes look so long and it’s easy to take off with just water, doesn’t smudge at all

This mascara is my OG. It was the first mascara that I bought that genuinely was waterproof and didn't smudge. The wand is small enough that it can get to all of the lashes. It's a really great mascara, but I struggle to find it in stock.

Huge fan of this, feel I can really coat all the lashes and so easy to remove 

Very disappointed with this purchase. Seems the money is spent on Overpriced and wasteful Packaging (metal casing). Have seen cheap drug store mascaras that have better wand and application. Mascara was dry and not many applications until there was nothing to use. 

I don't agree with all of the claims in the marketing/description of this mascara but it does'nt matter, this is the best mascara for me. I have sensitive eyes, especially during spring and summer due to allergies, and i need longevity, non irritating formula, and a mascara that keeps the curl without needing a huge and aggrevating effort to remove. This is it! It also gives me shiny really black lashes and separates them well. To remove this mascara is really satisfying and doesn't add to irritation of the eyes. Really expensive but worth it if youre eyes are anything like mine and you can afford it.

Lashes looked good but still ended up with panda eyes 

Love this - having battled with the dreaded panda eyes for so long and tried so many different formulations, waterproof, anti-smudge, tubing etc finally found this fantastic product that actually does the job.  Can wear all day without it moving, definition lengthening and separation are also great. It’s all very excellent will def re-purchase. Actually deserves more than five stars, please don’t discontinue this 

This is a good tubing mascara, but it is a shame that it doesn’t seem to be verified as cruelty free. It’s probably the best tubing mascara I have used (doesn’t really add length but does add volume) but I won’t repurchase unless it’s definitely verified as cruelty free. I will all brands were, as it would make getting good, cruelty free products so much easier! 

I always had a problem with panda eyes thst put me off wearing mascara. This never smudges. It is a tubing mascara and is so easy to remove. It gives decent volume and length. I am probably on my 10th tube by now!

Tubing mascara has changed my life - goodbye panda eyes! Have never looked back from this mascara!