Get 20% OFF 6 cult-classic brands: Drunk Elephant, Huda Beauty, Sunday Riley & more!

Westman Atelier Eye Love You Mascara

Customer Reviews

Westman Atelier Eye Love You Mascara Customer Reviews

GBP 54.0

£54.00

Westman Atelier Eye Love You Mascara
Overall Rating : 3.4 / 5 (10 Reviews)
  • 4 5 star reviews
  • 2 4 star reviews
  • 1 3 star reviews
  • 0 2 star reviews
  • 3 1 star reviews
3.4 / 5 (10 Reviews)
  • 4 5 star reviews
  • 2 4 star reviews
  • 1 3 star reviews
  • 0 2 star reviews
  • 3 1 star reviews

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Please remember that results will vary from person to person. We're proud to say that all customer reviews are independent, authentic and do not represent the views of Cult Beauty or The Hut Group.

Disappointed

1

Love Westman atelier, love the packaging … product so disappointing… doesn’t stay on the lashes … already little flakes dropping whilst apply … by lunchtime panda eyes … 

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (1)
Report this review

It grew on me!

4

I didn't initially like this for some reason, so I tried it once and called it a day, but still kept it because of the incredible packaging. Then one day I grabbed it again because I was in a rush and used the first mascara I found, and I received a lot of compliments about my lashes! I think where I was going wrong the first time around is that I didn't build it enough and it didn't look as dramatic as I like my lashes to be. The formula doesn't clump and really allows to layer on the product to achieve the level of intensity you want, I also find that it stays on all day long without smudging or flaking while keeping my lashes curled. I love that it's easy to remove and doesn't irritate my eyes and that the formula is super clean!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Terrible product

1

Read the reviews thought I give it ago, I was so disappointed. It did not last a full day by lunchtime it had crumbled all over my under eyes. I usually use Chanticalle which is more expensive but amazing so will be sticking with that. If you like just one light coat it maybe it would be ok however I like a few coats, if you’re like me do not buy.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Best I have ever used

5

Lengthens my lashes and feels like cream. Never crusty. It lasts all day without melting away even after exercising. I love the wand applicator . Genius!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Nice for everyday

4

I have been using this mascara over the last couple of days and I'm impressed with how it performs. It's a nice everyday mascara but you can definitely build it up if you wanted a little more volume and length. It also hasn't smudged on me, even after an entire day of wearing this (although I will mention I don't have particularly watery or sensitive eyes). Like all Westman Atelier products, the packaging is stunning, and this also comes with a cute little pouch too!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Gorgeous packaging and finish

3

The packaging of this is something else for a mascara, it comes in a beautiful pouch and it's such a unique mascara. I was pleasantly surprised that this held my curl fairly well, nothing but waterproof and the odd tubing mascara in the right formulation tends to work for me. So this is a big plus! It doesn't hold all day, but for a non-waterproof/non-tubing mascara this was so impressive! However, as a contact lens wearer I do get easily irritated eyes, and for me this did start to dry and irritate my eyes after a few hours. In terms of finish it is lovely, I'd say it's great for an every day look, but is also builable for a more dramatic lash. Not for me, but definitely for those without sensitive eyes!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

The most gorgeous, clean mascara

5

I am a huge fan of the entire Westman Atelier collection. This mascara is magical: healthy, clean, does not irritate my sensitive eyes (I am wearing contact lenses), and looks gorgeous on my lashes - it adds both, volume and length. Great staying power, easily removed, what's not to love. The price, maybe :)

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

I love you mascara

5

Best Mascara I have ever used! It lengthened my lashes so much they appear fake!! Feels like a cream, smooth application! Amazing!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Heartbroken

1

First of all, I am a fan of WA and before I purchased this mascara I also had a sample of it that I was pleased with. I can’t say that is was amazing but the benefits of it being clean were outweighing the price and the performance. I ordered it at the full price a month ago since I ran out of all my mascaras, even samples. But it is just awful, it is falling off while I am still applying it: all over my face, into my eyes, on my make up mirror. Glues the eyelashes together, leaves chunks on the tips of the eyelashes ... a complete disaster. Worst mascara I have used in a very very long time. I must say that I am used to high-quality mascaras, such as Chanel, Dior, Lancôme... Don’t know what to tell you, don’t want to turn you away from WA, the brand is nice, although not all products are equally good and fit all skin types (from my experience).

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

New Holy Grail

5

I am a mascara loyalist so it takes a lot to lure me away from my tried and tested favourites. A mascara has to tick a lot of boxes for me: volumising, lenghtening, no clumps, no smudging or flaking AND still be easily removable (no panda eyes of scrubbing for days to remove the last of it- no time for that.) This new mascara from Westman Atelier ticks all those boxes. Plus, have you seen that beautifully crafted gold tube? Feels like a little piece of everyday luxury for my lashes. A x

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (0)
Report this review

Westman Atelier Eye Love You Mascara Customer Reviews

GBP 54.0

£54.00

Westman Atelier Eye Love You Mascara

Quantity

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )