This did not work for me at all. I got this in the Caroline Hirons box and the first question I had was "why do I need a separate oil cleanser for my eyes?" I double cleanse and my normal oil cleansers wash everything away, including stubborn eye makeup (Tata Harper. Get it.). Having to use something separate for my eyes makes it such a hassle. In any case, I decided to try it since I had it on hand. The oil is nice, it smells good, but it's thick. It takes away 95% of makeup, but somehow still left some of my glitter eyeliner behind (for the record, Tata's does a better job at that). The worst part of it though, is that it does not emulsify. Despite the bottle stating that you can "rinse off" (alternative provided was wiping off, but I don't like that), the oil stays put like there's no tomorrow. The feeling after applying water in an attempt to rinse it off was not pleasant - it was sticky, gunky and gooey, and it got into my eyes. I ended up having to wipe it off with a muslin cloth (which defeats the purpose of it being gentle because I'm wiping my eye area!) and following up with another cleanser to remove any residue. Including this in my skincare regime means I'll have to triple cleanse. No thanks.